Ep. 19 Extras: Snape Good, Bad, or Grey?

We discuss various events in Snape’s life and decide if they’re Good, Bad, Grey, or N/A

Event	Good	Grey	Bad	N/A
Watched girls with “greed”				x
Befriended Lily, told her about magic	x
Made branch fall on Petunia –?		x(d)		x
Disdain for Muggles		x
Friends with Lily most of school	x
Fascinated with Dark Arts		x
Called Lily a Mudblood			x
Laughed at housemate’s pranks		x
Became a Death Eater			x
Relayed prophecy to Voldemort			x
Asked Voldemort to spare Lily	x
Asked Dumbledore to protect Lily	x
– And didn’t include James and Harry		x		x
Pledged to do “anything” for DD	x
Spied for the Order	x
Is a very sarcastic person				x
Was a hardass teacher				x
Bullied Neville, Trevor?		x	x(d,m)
Insulted Hermione, hurts her feelings		x	x(d,m)	x
Bullied Harry		x
Protected Harry multiple times	x
– PS Quidditch	x
– CoS watched for Harry & Ron	x
Taught Harry Expelliarmus	x
– PoA goes to Shrieking Shack	x
Making Woldsbane for Lupin	x
“Outing” Lupin	x
Sprinting to 4th floor in his nightshirt	x
– GoF goes back to spy on V/mort	x
– OoP gives Umbitch fake veritaserum	x
Tried to teach Harry occlumency		x
Unbreakable vow	x
Saved DD, slowed curse	x
Killed Dumbledore	x
and saved Draco’s soul	x
Stopped Harry being crucio’d	x
As Headmaster protected students	x
Delivered Sword to Harry	x
Doesn’t tell Vmort about wands real master	x
Gives Harry memories	x